[CNBC] Coronavirus cases in China overtake SARS — and the economic impact could be 'more severe'
EuropaNewswire | Gado | Getty Images
The number of coronavirus cases in China has already surpassed that of SARS, and the economic impact of the new virus from Wuhan could be more severe than the 2002-2003 epidemic, or at least similar, according to economists.
It took more than 6 months for the number of SARS cases to surpass 5,000 in mainland China. China had 5,327 SARS cases between Nov. 1 2002 and July 31 2003, according to the World Health Organization.
On the other hand, it's taken about a month for the number of new coronavirus cases to climb past 5,000 on Tuesday. The new virus was first officially reported in the Chinese city of Wuhan on Dec. 31.
According to China's National Health Commission, the number of cases in mainland China stood at 5,974 at the end of Tuesday, up from 4,515 the prior day.
Initial figures from the government indicate a death rate of between 2% and 3% in China for the new virus, compared to a mortality rate of about 7% for SARS.
The Wuhan coronavirus, which could lead to a type of pneumonia, has sparked alarm as it comes from the same family of viruses as SARS which killed some 800 people. The latest outbreak has killed 132 in China as of Wednesday's update.
"There are reasons to worry about this time around compared to SARS because first of all, the connectivity in terms of transportation and economy is much greater nowadays (as compared) to the SARS episode," Tommy Wu, senior economist at Oxford Economics, told CNBC on Wednesday.
The disease has spread beyond Wuhan to Beijing, Shanghai and other highly populated cities in the country. Cases in other parts of Asia such as Thailand, Japan, Singapore and South Korea, have also been reported. In Europe, cases have been reported in France and Germany, and the United States currently has 5 confirmed cases.
Wu also flagged the timing of the outbreak, which took place just before the Lunar New Year holiday, when hundreds of millions of Chinese traveled domestically and internationally to be with their families during the festivities.
"The timing is also important because this time around is during Chinese New Year, where there are mass movements of citizens around the country going back home for family reunion. And during the next couple weeks, there'll be a massive flow coming back from home to the cities they work," Wu said. "That's why it's possible that this time around the impact could be more severe than during the SARS episode."
"Even if the coronavirus outbreak is brought under control quicker than SARS was in 2003, the economic impact now looks likely to be of at least a similar scale," wrote Mark Williams, chief Asia economist at Capital Economics in a note on Monday.
According to an estimate by Capital Economics, SARS lowered China's growth by three percentage points in its worst-affected quarter. Overall, growth slowed from 8% year-on-year to 5% during that outbreak.
"The very limited data available so far suggest that the current impact is not yet that severe but it could end up being similar," Williams said. "But it is now certain that the outbreak will have a significant impact on China's GDP this quarter."
Travel restrictions and services halted
He cited the slowdown in activity within China. Beyond the Lunar New Year holiday, Shanghai has told businesses to remain shut for an additional week, while travel restrictions are in place in around 20 cities. Many long-distance bus and high-speed rail services have also been halted.
"On top of these ... steps, many businesses such as restaurants have chosen to close and people are avoiding crowded places," Williams said.
He flagged that rail passenger numbers on Saturday - the first day of the Lunar New Year - was 42% lower compared to the equivalent 2019 period, while road passenger traffic decreased by 25%.
In May 2003 - the peak month of the SARS outbreak - year-on-year declines were 57% for rail passenger traffic and 45% for road passenger traffic, Williams said.
"While the more open and proactive official response this time may prove more effective in containing the virus, it could also make the initial economic disruption larger," he pointed out.
How the coronavirus is hitting business The Australian Financial Review
Global spread of coronavirus: Countries with confirmed cases Daily Nation
China records first virus death in Beijing as toll passes 100 Reuters
WHO raises coronavirus risk level RACGP
'It's racist': Outrage over fake note listing 'coronavirus suburbs to avoid' Yahoo News Australia
More News in Business
Philippine Information Agency 29th January 2020, 19:38 GMT+11 TUGUEGARAO CITY, Cagayan, Jan. 29 (PIA) - The Department of Health - Cagayan Valley Center for Health and Development here has already prepared measures against novel coronavirus (2019
British Airways has suspended all flights between Heathrow and Beijing and Shanghai after the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) issued a warning against all but essential travel to mainland China amid the spread of the
Gold edged higher on Wednesday after falling 1% in the previous session, on elevated concerns over an economic impact of the coronavirus outbreak in China, while investors awaited a policy decision from the U.S. Federal
BEIJING - The United States and Japan flew citizens out of the Chinese city at the epicenter of a new virus outbreak on Wednesday, as the death toll rose sharply to 132 and the first
DUBAI, United Arab Emirates - The first cases of the deadly coronavirus in the Middle East have been confirmed in the United Arab Emirates, the country's Ministry of Health and Community Protection said in a